Safer & Healthier

By Mike Friend

Pittsburgh's home stock is aging, which can contribute to potential health and safety issues for vulnerable older residents. The Healthy Home Lab aims to help them to age in place with innovation, policy and practice. 

The Pittsburgh metro area has the second-oldest population in the country, with an average of nearly 43 years. Like its population, Pittsburgh's homes are also aging—with the average home age of more than 84 years, many of which were built up, not out, to deal with the area's hilly terrain. 

With the 65+ population expected to double by 2050 and more than 92% of adults 55 and older preferring to stay in their homes as long as possible, there are concerns about whether these homes are ready for people choosing to age in place. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) says just four in 10 are. 

"The home is a place of health. HUD says that on the landing page of its website," said Steven Albert, PhD, MA, MS, professor of behavioral and community health sciences, School of Public Health. "So, if you improve the health of the home, do you improve the health of people who live in the home?"

Pitt's Healthy Home Lab (HHL) is a community-based laboratory staffed by an interdisciplinary team of researchers with a goal to make aging in place easier through innovation, policy and practice. The home in Pittsburgh's Oakland neighborhood was built in 1860 and was owned by the same family for more than 100 years. HHL acquired the home in 2022. 

In addition to their age, the condition of Pittsburgh homes ranks poorly on average. One in 20 does not meet HUD standards for "suitable living environments." Pittsburgh also has the highest percentage of homes with severe deficiencies in the U.S., including problems with structural integrity, heating, plumbing, electrical systems and pest infestations—all of which contribute to what HUD calls "unrecognized environmental hazards." 

Aging in Place

A closer look at the tech and potential trouble spots tested by Healthy Home Lab researchers

An eye above

A ceiling light with a camera inside can call for help if it sees a fall. HHL testers say it's not 100% accurate—it does record most correct—but gets a few false positives, too. Sometimes the simplest solutions are the most effective, such as replacing the type of pulls on a cabinet to make it easier to open and close. 

Mobility and accessibility
bed rail

Other improvements tested yielded positive results: a handrail can help users sit up in bed or keep them from rolling out in the middle of the night. But it's also easy to catch a finger or arm inside its bars. 

hand rail

A sturdy security pole can help people sit and stand easily—but they're not all made equal—the HHL team had to modify this one to anchor it to the high ceilings. 

table

HHL engineer Todd Hargroder designed this wheelchair friendly table so that users could slide in anywhere, not just the end. It also has a lip on the underside to help non-wheelchair users stand up after a meal. 

Tech assistance
motion sensor

Advances in technology continue to provide new avenues of assistance. Small motion detectors, placed bedside, can automatically turn on the lights to help eliminate trips and falls during late-night bathroom visits. 

ElliQ

Visitors to HHL love this tabletop robot named ElliQ, which asks and answers questions, offers advice for keeping active and even writes poetry. However, the HHL team is less enthusiastic; while she may help to curb loneliness, she's expensive, lacks functionality and, sometimes, just won't keep quiet. Their solution is to pretend it's time for bed: "Goodnight, ElliQ."

Alexa

Also present in the lab, Alexa isn't as cute as ElliQ, but she's a problem solver. With simple commands, she can tackle a host of handy tasks like ordering groceries, setting medication reminders, locking doors and turning lights on and off. Plus, it's one of the more affordable options in the home technology realm. 

Mobius

HHL's premier product, Mobius, is an adaptable rail system that can be installed throughout a house and reconfigured as the user's needs and abilities change. 

Mobius

Its components—including grab bars, handrails and stair assist devices—are easily attached, removed and repositioned with a quick snap. And when not in use, it looks like a decorative chair rail. The project is being supported by a $2 million grant and is on the cusp of commercialization. 

""
Mindful caution

Potential trouble can be averted: a low-profile sofa may beg the question: If you sit down, will you be able to get back up? Placing risers under couch or chair legs transforms low seats into higher, manageable ones. Plus, they're readily available and affordable. A rug with elevated edges could pose a trip hazard to some. 

rug sticking up at corner

Text excerpted and adapted from Pitt Magazine.

Photography by Aimee Obidzinski

If we're looking at the home as a place of health, we want to find out if it is a place of morbidity, too, because certain hazards, especially conditions associated with air quality," said Albert. 

Unrecognized environmental hazards like poor indoor air quality, moisture, mold and other fungal species can interfere with pre-existing health conditions or affect the delivery of in-home services. 

In a city like Pittsburgh, where outdoor air quality is also a major concern, Albert and his team at the HHL have found a way to incorporate questions about exposure to these hazards into people's access to in-home supportive care. The project was funded through a grant from HUD, the first of its kind awarded to the University, and resulted in the creation of the Healthy Homes Assessment Tool (H-HAT). 

"At first, we looked at what environmental hazard assessments were already in place for home- and community-based services," said Meredith Hughes, JD, MPH, assistant professor of health policy and management. "We found that of the tools out there, only 10% had mentions of environmental hazards." 

In partnership with the Allegheny County Agency on Aging and others, the team developed H-HAT to assess air quality and suggest mitigation strategies in more than 40 homes in Greater Pittsburgh. 

"The residents who took part (in the H-HAT development process) were already receiving services and many had already received elaborate home assessments, but these were limited to accessibility, safety, and maybe heat and temperature," added Albert. "Nobody was looking at PM2.5, mold or carbon monoxide, which all can affect pulmonary or cardiovascular health, especially if someone has other comorbidities." 

PM2.5 is particulate matter that is 2.5 micrometers or fewer in diameter. For comparison, a single human hair is 70 micrometers in diameter. PM2.5 are microscopic solids or liquid droplets that are so small they can be inhaled deep into the lungs and cause serious health problems if they enter the bloodstream or brain. 

The H-HAT assessment combined policy, environmental health science, and civil and environmental engineering with public health. At first, researchers did a feasibility study, creating a questionnaire that could be easily added to in-home assessments—and easily judged, like seeing mold on a surface—and then compared these reports to sensor readings. Other questions asked about smokers in the home or the use of natural gas for heating and cooking, as well as radon, an odorless and invisible radioactive gas naturally released from rocks, soil, and water, which is more prevalent in Pittsburgh because of its geology. 

H-HAT teams were also challenged to find metrics to measure some environmental hazards. For that, they relied on Jemima Ohwobete, MEng, a PhD student in the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering at Pitt's Swanson School of Engineering. 

"We see a lot of cases, especially with older people, where they get sick, go to the hospital, get better and when they come home what made them sick—especially if it's mold or other microbes—is still there," said Ohwobete. "We wanted to find a low-cost consumer home air monitor that was as close to the gold standard as possible and also easy to use and understand." 

Ohwobete says much of her work focused on controllable in-home habits that affect air quality like air flow, light and temperature. To test theories and help formulate suggestions after the assessments, researchers used the Healthy Home Lab for just what its name implies, as a laboratory. 

"In the home, the more it is or the darker it is, mold loves it," said Ohwobete, who used rooms at the Healthy Home Lab to experiment with how sunlight, ventilation and temperature affected mold growth. She called it a way to experiment in a practical setting outside of a laboratory. 

After the assessments and measurements, H-HAT researchers needed a way to communicate their findings with the residents that made sense. 

"A lot of thought went into how we shared the information," said Albert. "We compared household results to regional and sample averages since every area is different. We also decided to give the results to the agencies doing the assessment, along with remediation tips that the person going into the home can discuss with the residents and answer questions." 

For some homes, remediation could be costly, but Hughes said much of the work on the policy side of the research is finding ways to use resources already available. 

"There are agencies and resources out there that are dedicated to helping people make their homes safer," she said. "For example, the Whole Home Repair program (funded by the Pennsylvania Department of Community and Economic Development) has funding to remediate things like asbestos, mold and pests—all of which can contribute to air quality concerns." 

With the work on H-HAT wrapping up, leaders with the HHL say the goal is to continue to expand the sturdy and improve home health to the point that environmental hazards no longer place people at risk for preventable health complications.